The tax authorities and the fictitious returns in Box 3: the biggest blunder of the past 10 years

Was this the biggest mistake made by the tax authorities in the past 10 years?
It is a question that many people are asking themselves now that the consequences of the unfair taxation in Box 3 are becoming increasingly clear. Between 2017 and 2022, the tax authorities charged tax on a fictitious return, while the actual return was much lower for many people. This error was eventually recognized by the Supreme Court and has now led to a recovery settlement for 2.3 million Dutch people.

For years, the tax authorities used a fixed fictitious return, even if this did not at all match the actual return that taxpayers received on their assets. In reality, many Dutch people achieved lower returns on their savings, investments or real estate than the tax authorities assumed. This led to a system where more wealth was taxed than people actually owned.

The consequences of the error

This error has had enormous consequences for millions of Dutch people who paid too much tax for years as a result. Exactly how much money is involved? Experts estimate that the total amount of unduly paid tax in recent years has amounted to billions of euros. Most notably, it was only after years of litigation and social pressure that the government decided to reinstate the case.

The recovery scheme that is now in force is seen by many as a necessary step to return the amount of tax paid unfairly to those affected. The government has made a €10 billion pot available for this purpose. But unfortunately, the refund doesn't come automatically — taxpayers have to take action themselves.

How was the error corrected?

Fortunately, the government finally acknowledged that this way of taxing was not correct. Since 2021, the tax authorities have set up a scheme to refund unduly paid tax. But, as is already clear, you have to take action yourself to get the refund. And that's where Box3.nl helps you.

Our specialists ensure that your actual return is calculated, your situation is properly substantiated legally and fiscally, and your application is submitted to the tax authorities. This is how we ensure that you receive the full recovery amount — and not the flat-rate refund, which is usually much lower.

What can you do to get your recovery?

• Check if you are entitled to a refund: This can be done quickly and free of charge via Box3.nl.
• Have your actual return calculated: We provide the correct calculations and legal substantiation.
• Submit your application: We will contact the tax authorities and ensure the progress of your recovery.

The biggest blunder, but also an opportunity

Although the mistakes of the tax authorities had enormous consequences for millions of Dutch people, the recovery scheme now offers an opportunity to get the tax paid unfairly back. However, it's important to understand that you shouldn't miss this opportunity. The tax authorities will not take action if you do not submit an application.

So it's up to you now to make sure you get what you're entitled to. Don't leave money behind and make sure you take action before it's too late.

Why wait? Let Box3.nl help you and find out how much you can get back.

‍